Forum disputes: “get it right first time”

As I said at the outset, I was persuaded to give permission to appeal because it appeared that a question of principle might arise. With the benefit of argument, I doubt whether that is so. However, this appeal will have served a useful purpose if it underlines the importance, in this context as elsewhere, of…

Read more

Can you strike out without submitting to the jurisdiction?

We know from cases like PJSC Bank “Finance And Credit” & Anor v Valentynovich & Ors [2021] EWHC 2522 (Ch) at [67] and Tsareva v Ananyev [2019] EWHC 2414 (Comm) at [60] that defendants have been allowed to issue conjoined applications disputing the court’s jurisdiction while simultaneously applying for strike-out or summary judgment without this…

Read more

Court of Appeal: English law governs tort claims for mistreatment at CIA “black sites”

In Zubaydah v Foreign And Commonwealth Office & Ors [2022] EWCA Civ 334, the Court of Appeal considered which law should apply to tort claims against the State based on the Claimant’s extreme mistreatment and torture at “black sites” at the hands of the CIA between 2002 and 2006. Lane J had held that the…

Read more

Forum conveniens

We previously wrote about how, following the Supreme Court’s approach in Brownlie II, the likelihood is that “proper forum” disputes will form a major battleground in future international injury litigation. It seems that the first wave of such cases is already arriving, as illustrated by the recent failure of a forum challenge in Klifa v…

Read more

Cross-border clinical negligence claims

There are few cases dealing with breach of duty in cross-border clinical negligence litigation. However, the rising number of claims arising out of botched cosmetic surgery carried out abroad means that this is an issue of increasing significance. Clarke v Kalecinski & Ors [2022] EWHC 488 (QB) is an interesting and timely decision. Foster J…

Read more

Tour operator delay in providing refunds breached Package Travel Regulations

This week, defunct tour operators Teletext Holidays and Alpharooms.com were declared to have breached the Package Travel and Linked Travel Arrangements Regulations 2018 for their delay in providing refunds for holidays cancelled by COVID-19. The judgment, in a claim brought by the Competition and Markets Authority against two tour operators, will also be of collateral interest to travel practitioners. Unusually,…

Read more